Showing posts with label grunge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label grunge. Show all posts

Monday, October 25, 2010

SPOTLIGHT: Decline of Hair Metal pre-"Nevermind"

There's a common narrative that has long since spilled over from academic / journalist circles into public discourse: in 1991, hair metal bands like Poison, Motley Crue, Winger, etc still ruled over the kingdom of pop music, their reign unchallenged and seemingly bulletproof until Nirvana came along in September of that year and banished the hairspray and Spandex brigade to the hinterlands, never to be heard from again.

Well, I'm not here to argue the idea that Nevermind changed the popular music landscape - that it certainly did - but there is a decided bit of myth making to the other end of the argument that it's high time was exposed, that being the idea that hair metal was still in a sanguine state at the time. On the contrary, as we'll see below, hair metal peaked around 1987-88 and by two years later was already a shadow of its former self.


Tuesday, July 6, 2010

1990: "Shove", L7

Not that Courtney Love and Kat Bjelland were the only formerly interrelated band members attempting to establish themselves with a similar sound. Jennifer Finch had also played with Love and Bjelland in Sugar Baby Doll. As it turns out, L7 were first to make it to record with 1988's L7, but at this point it's nearly impossible to unravel which of these women was most instrumental in defining the sandblasted, grunge punk sound all three bands would become associated with, or to what extent the evolution was a group effort.

"Shove" was the lead off single from 1990's Smell the Magic

1990: "Swamp Pussy", Babes in Toyland

In fairness to Courtney Love, she and Kat Bjelland played together in several unrecorded bands before going their separate ways to form Hole and Babes in Toyland, respectively, but though both women argued incessantly over whom originally came up with the tattered baby doll look and throat shredding punk sound both bands early became known for, it seems that the majority of their mutual bandmates side with Bjelland on this issue. Either way, it's hard to argue that Love wasn't the first to cash in her underground credentials.

1990: "Retard Girl", Hole

1990 also marked the debut, non-album single from Hole. Listeners only familiar with "Doll Parts" and "Malibu" may be surprised at the heavy, almost noise rock quality of this early offering, but before we go giving Courtney Love too much credit our next entry will show where a huge chunk of her "influence" came from. This is still a pretty strong debut, any way you slice it, though.

1990: "Not a Lot to Save", Gruntruck

A sadly forgotten grunge band as (potentially) mainstream as Alice in Chains or Soundgarden, Gruntruck sported a couple of Skin Yard castoffs (Ben McMillan - vocals, guitar; Scott McCullum - drums) and guitarist Tom Niemayer of local splatterpunks The Accused. Gruntruck came front loaded with a shitload of promise, opening for the likes of Pantera and AiC before signing a long term deal with metal heavyweight Roadrunner Records, but success never panned out for the band, and after starting off the 1990s with a pair of well produced albums, the band spent the middle part of the decade battling to get out of their fruitless contract with Roadrunner.

In 1996, Gruntruck finally became free again and released one last three song EP through an indie label, but in the ensuing years their momentum had been lost, their second wave grunge sound had become antiquated, and the band amicably went their separate ways. Frontman Ben McMillan died in 2008, most likely dooming this once mighty group's legacy to a grunge footnote. Too bad.

1990: "Black Glove", The Fluid

C/Z may (or may not) have gotten to grunge first, but Sub Pop was quicker to break out of the Pac NW market, signing Denver act The Fluid - as grunge as any motherfuckers outside of Seattle - to a deal in time to release their 1988 record, Clear Black Paper. Since I'm starting this blog at 1990 there's a lot of early grunge shit being overlooked, but this song from 1990's Glue EP shows The Fluid was still kicking strong several releases into their career.

1990: "Loser", Tad

Speaking of Tad, a pretty worthy follow up to Skin Yard. Tad - named after frontman Tad Doyle but intended to be separately considered as a band name - could retrospectively be written off as a too-sloppy-for-primetime sister band to the Melvins, but these early recordings were largely of their time: heavy on the treble and bass with as much of the mid-range scooped out as possible, this was largely an attempt to embrace 70s metal while still roughly adhering to punk's aesthetic values (an ethos Black Flag's My War and subsequent recordings went a long way toward fostering)

1990: "Ritual Room", Skin Yard

As if to emphasize the extent to which the metallic, Stooges-meet-Sabbath vibe dominated the Pac NW scene prior to Nirvana's mainstream breakthrough, consider Skin Yard. One of the oldest Seattle bands peddling what would later be called grunge, Skin Yard formed in 1985 and by 1986 had already released their first album on C/Z Records (the label that issued the seminal proto-grunge comp Deep Six in March of 1986 and arguably the first full blown grunge label period).

Apologies in advance for the shoddy recording quality of this clip, but Skin Yard just never got enough love to warrant preservation of their performances, apparently. I wanted this song in particular since it has that perfect mix of Mudhoney's screeching vocal mannerisms and Tad's bottom heavy Sabbath worship.

After releasing 1990's Fist Sized Chunks - from which "Ritual Room" is taken - Skin Yard stuck around until 1993, releasing two more poor selling records before finally conceding to lack of interest in the shadows of their peers.

1990: "Real Thing", Alice in Chains

People who think that Nirvana's Nevermind came along in Sept. 1991 and single handedly vanquished the hitherto indestructible hair metal scene often forget one important thing: bands like Alice in Chains and Soundgarden had already established themselves as staples on heavy metal radio and Headbanger's Ball more than a year prior to that.

In fact, looking back from the vantage point of someone who was immersed in metal to the exclusion of all else at the time, bands like Alice in Chains and Soundgarden largely fit in with an amorphous clump of disparate, "artsy" metal that was becoming prominent in the late 80s... Faith No More, Primus, Warrior Soul, King's X, etc. Admittedly, there was little mainstream buzz around the word "grunge" or a Seattle scene until post-Nevermind, but whether or not hair metal was still a healthy concern in its own right by late 1991 is a subject I hope to tackle in more depth later.

Facelift is less focused than subsequent Alice in Chains efforts but already demonstrates a consistent flair for songwriting. A listen to their early demos, which finds the band flailing between their polished, hair metal roots and the moodier angst of their Columbia Records stint, offers a pretty solid education into the different musical directions they struggled through at the time.

"Real Thing" - coincidentally also the title of Faith No More's breakthrough album - was one of the more uncharacteristic songs on Facelift, which by default makes it one of the strangest entries in the entire AiC catalog. An apocalyptic death-blues number, what it lacks in innovation lyrically it more than demonstrates in guitarist Jerry Cantrell's flair with a riff... probably AiC's biggest ace in the hole this early in their career.

1990: "Bone China", Mother Love Bone

Grunge seems like as good a place as any to start the dawn of the 90s. It's funny: we look back now and see grunge as a fairly cohesive sound (due in large part to a lot of grunge-influenced bands that later sprung up, consolidating hard rock radio into a post-grunge landscape that narrowed it all down to the heavier Seattle groups like Alice In Chains and Soundgarden; see Bush, Sponge, Stone Temple Pilots, etc). But at the time the Pacific Northwest was hardly in agreement on what "grunge" should sound like (or even that there should be such an umbrella term at all). The common denominator was that it was once again OK to be into metal as well as punk... but the format and the proportions with which that alchemy was sought varied wildly from one group to another.

Perhaps the most traditional of all the bands retroactively described as capital-g Grunge were Mother Love Bone. The band had already outgrown any overt hair metal leanings before making it to record, but their solution wasn't so much a punked up hybrid of Sabbath and Black Flag as a modernized, contemporary updating of the bombastic 70s arena rock sound (a musical vein Janes Addiction had been mining on their own terms further south). This was a far cry from Stone Gossard and Jeff Ament's prior band, Green River, but following MLB frontman Andrew Wood's heroin overdose in March 1990, the duo would go on to form Pearl Jam, itself a successful marriage of dirty punk squalor and soaring arena rock.